What would have happened had Saul----- ( paul) refused jesus on the damascus road?
James replies:
In the middle of the Day, WHILE saul was going to KILL Christians, God lights up a blinding light and speaks to him Audibly, and then sends a dream to Ananias and tells him who to look for and where, and also tells Paul in a dream who is coming to see him, so they can EACH confirm it with each other!
God BLINDED Paul for THREE DAYS!!!!
So much for free will on that one!
This is what the Bible says happens, in order:
1. Fallen sinful man with will enslaved to sin, and totally spiritually dead, has been chosen by God before the world was made.
2. Holy Spirit comes to man, and MAKES him INTO a new Creature with a NEW will.
3. Man, who is now spiritually alive, DESIRES to repent and trust in Jesus, and man does so.
4. God CAUSES his chosen people to persevere to the end, which is either physical death, or the Lord returning.
dgrimater continues:
What about the jews they are Gods chosen people. They chose to reject God and the church was adapted in?
James replies:
God just expands His chosen people (from our viewpoint) as time goes on. First it was Abraham, then the Jews, and then When the Messiah came, it was expanded to ALL KINDS of people from ALL OVER THE WORLD. (John 3:16)
dgrimater continues:
What if I decided to follow Jesus but I am not the elect?
Then am I wasting my time?
James replies:
No one BUT the elect will follow Jesus, and if you are trusting in Christ, then the Bible says you ARE saved.
There is no such thing as losing your salvation, because YOU didn't get it in the first place!
You repented and trusted in Jesus?
Well, Ephesians 2:8,9 says that faith itself is a gift from God.
GOD has saved you! God who has started a good work in you will complete it!
Yes, we as Christians should examine ourselves from time to time, to see if we are in the faith. The Question is, "Am I truly born again?"
But please don't lose sight of the FACT that fallen mankind does NOT want to repent and trust in Jesus. I have had extremely honest types tell me that they didn't want to go to heaven because there was no sin there!
The ONLY people who want to follow Jesus and trust in Him, ARE ALREADY born again, by the Holy Spirit.
Joh 6:37 All that the Father giveth me shall come to me; and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out.
Joh 15:16 Ye have not chosen me, but I have chosen you, and ordained you, that ye should go and bring forth fruit, and that your fruit should remain: that whatsoever ye shall ask of the Father in my name, he may give it you.
Leon and James I ask you these questions.
I am curious.
James replies:
Here is one for you dgrimater:
Question: In Acts the Apostles were preaching to a CROWD of people. Out of this crowd, EXACTLY how many accepted Jesus?
Act 13:48 And when the Gentiles heard this, they were glad, and glorified the word of the Lord: and as many as were ordained to eternal life believed.
if you are speaking about the speech of peter and John over 3,000 in one day. The one you gave me in a verse was all that got saved.
I asked you these questions to find out what you really think. I know some accuse and call names. I wanted to make sure I did not do that here. So, if we disagreed it would be just a disagreement. Over all, I just disagree with you on one point.
if you beieve in once saved always saved I would question that. That is the only thing I disagree with your reply.
James you keep saying what the bible says, and we can see for ourselves what it says, and it does not agree with you, so where is the misunderstanding?
Are we to believe that you are the word of God.
Dennis why would you say you agree with this unbelief?
I don't really like the phrase "Once saved, always saved."
The classic historic doctrine is called
"The perseverance of the Saints."
The saying "Once saved, always saved" is a Baptist saying, and it is a problem because the Baptists ALSO teach the Decisional idea in Salvation.
In other words, in Baptist churches you "walk the Aisle".
You stand up in front of church, and say, "Yes I believe in Jesus".
Well, here is the problem, those two things together, have been used as an excuse for people who are not saved, to rationalize that they are.
They went in front of the church when they were young, and many years later they don't attend church, and have no evidence in their lives of being born again, and if you ask them about it, you get:
"Hey, I walked the Aisle, once saved, ALWAYS saved, buddy!"
That is why it is a bad idea. I was a member of a Baptist church as a new Christian, and it was a wonderful place to be filled with many great Christians. But the way they combine those two things is not the best way to do it.
And you might have guessed that since "The Perseverance of the Saints, IS one of the five points, that I DO have a scripture list, for that point.
I think you can see how these things are hooked together.
IF.....God chose His own people for Himself before the world was made.
AND....none of God's purposes can be thwarted.
And....God had Jesus die for them specifically.
And....had the Holy Spirit come and make each one of them alive spiritually.
THEN....naturally, God has decided to CAUSE His people to persevere to the end.
James if one was to go by the evidence if you were saved knowing what you post, there is no evidence of salvation, or any fruit there of, all that is there is Calvinism.
I did not say that to be argumentative, but to answer your question.
Ima back with a Monkey Wrench ta toss into the Spokes of Folks...
" Election " as in the Bible the WORD is refering to the JEWS...They are the Elected...The Chosen People of GOD...an that is UNCONDITIOAL...We GENTILES are the BELOVED of GOD...NOT the Elect...xo
PJ, in further response to your statement, I have this to say;
I was not there when Saul/ Paul had his encounter with Jesus.
It is a fact some people may be pushed very hard to serve God.Saul/ Paul needed a wake up call. I do not know if paul was given a choice. if he had refused the call what would have happened?????????
Who would have wrote so much?
Paul was a religious man.
Who are we to say that some men may not have a choice?
Well, I do not believe Paul wanted to go to hell.
James, my going back to school has helped me ask questions Like my teachers do. I find this to be challenging. Instead of saying that I am right I ask to get a response from somebody to see what they are thinking. Instead of argueing I find this to be more educational. I have changed some of my thinking.
I did notice we have a few different views on things.
Sorry, I didn't notice your questions until now. I think James represented it well. I would add that we believe you will not seek God without His first calling you.
Here is part of a letter I am writing, I think it explains it well.
Let me know if it does not.
First, salvation is all of God and none of me. I did not choose God, He chose me. (John 15:16) In our natural state, we have no use for God. We don't understand Him, nor do we want to understand. (1Cor.2:9-14, Romans 3:9-19) It is only after God changes our heart and sends His Spirit that we start to seek Him. (Eze. 36:26) We are born in sin (Psalms 51) and have no hope for salvation because we don't want it. God calls us (Romans 9) and gives us the ability to see the things of God. We eventually reach a point where we do have to choose, but it is not really a choice. Who would ever choose their old life compared to the one God is offering? No one I know! (Heb. 6:4, 5)
Now, since we know that there is nothing we can do on our own to change how God sees us, we have to admit that it is only our acceptance of Christ that can save us. That leads us to, can we ever do anything that would anger Him so badly that we could lose our salvation? The short answer is, no, you cannot. I know that sounds odd, but you have to remember, salvation is a free gift because of what Jesus did, not because of what we did. So can you do something so bad that God would turn His back on Jesus? Of course not! Jesus is seated at the right hand of the Father. His resurrection and ascension guarantees your spot. He did all the work, we just ride in on His coattails.
There is a beautiful example of this in Eze. 16. It is a Messianic Prophesy, but it shows how our relationship with God works, and the end shows that He does not take our salvation, though we will pay a price for disobedience.
I just wanted to say thank you for your help and support.
You sound like you attend a great church, and have a real good understanding of the Bible. That is something that is rare these days. Anyways, thanks again!